Technology for Educators

May 7, 2009

The Smartboard Alternative for $40

Filed under: Presentations — Sue Frantz @ 1:45 pm
Tags: , ,

There you are in class and you write on your whiteboard (or chalkboard, I hear those still exist) the most perfect explanation of whatever it is you explain. Wouldn’t you love to be able to save that to share with future students? Or perhaps you’re part way through the material you want to cover when class ends. Don’t you wish you could save what you’ve written so you could start there next class? Do you find that the linearity of PowerPoint is starting to wear you down? Wouldn’t you love to just point at a spot on the screen and zip to the slide you want? Or wouldn’t it be nice to access the internet without moving from the front of the room? Don’t you wish you had a few thousand dollars laying around for a smartboard?

This is me writing on the screen using an infrared pen. The displayed program is Classroom Presenter.

What if I told you that you can have all of the functionality above for about $40 (assuming you already have a projector and a computer)?Wii remote: $30 

Trip to Radio Shack: $7.50*

Dried up dry erase marker: free

Simulated smartboard: priceless

If your computer is not Bluetooth enabled, you’ll need a USB Bluetooth dongle (that’s what they’re called, I swear!): $3

If you already have a Wii remote, then that’s free. The price of this project just dropped to practically nothing!

*This cost does not include the $8 soldering kit, the $7 for the spools of wire, and because some parts are sold in pairs, you’ll probably want to make two pens.

Before we play MacGyver, I’m going to send you to watch Johnny Lee show you how this works in a 5-minute TED talk video. If you like what you see, come back, and I’ll get you set up with everything you need.

[Seriously, go watch the video.]

We’re going to use a Wii remote to act as the conduit between your classroom’s screen and your computer. We’re going to use an infrared pen to tell the Wii remote what to tell the computer. In short, we’re going to do what Lee did. If you combine this Wii remote setup with Classroom Presenter (see my 4/14/2009 blog post), you will have a powerful interactive whiteboard.

What you need.

1. Wii remote. That’s easy. You can use the one that came with your Wii – you’re not going to do anything to it other than tote it to class. It will still work just the same way with your Wii system. You don’t have a Wii system? You can buy a Wii remote wherever game systems are sold.

2. Infrared pen. This is a little harder. You can order them online from $8 to $30. IRPensOnline and Penteractive are two such sites [Update: Some sellers have pressure-activated pens if you’d rather not use a thumb switch]. (Disclaimer: I haven’t used either retailer. Sites are provided only for informational purposes.) Or you can make your own (thus the trip to Radio Shack). I used the instructions from Ken Moore of Ken Moore Design. He includes a how-to video, written instructions, and a (printable) Radio Shack shopping list complete with part numbers. I opted to use a dried up EXPO dry-erase marker because we seem to have those in abundance. You know where to find them. In your classroom, it’s usually the first one you pick up. Because some of the parts you need are sold in pairs it makes sense to make two pens. You should always have a back-up anyway.

Tips for making the pen.

a. Ken’s shopping list doesn’t include wire. I used 22-gauge – definitely something on the smaller side is better. Wires have to be stuffed into the marker with the battery holder so the smaller they are, the easier everything fits.

b. When he says that force is needed to get the LED holder into the tip of the marker, he is not joking. I used a drill to bore the tip to make it a little wider, particularly around the opening. I think this made it easier for the threads of the LED holder to bite. Once they did, screwing it in wasn’t hard. Lots of force to get it started. Seriously.

c. For my pen, small, needle-nose pliers will be needed to change the battery. I’ll worry about that when the time comes.

d. One person recommended a daub of super glue to hold the LED in place in the holder – not a bad idea.

e. Since the LED is infrared, by definition, you can’t see it when it’s lit. Please remember this after you followed the instructions to the letter, push the switch, and nothing seems to happen. Dig out your digital camera or flip on your cell phone’s camera, press the pen’s switch, and look at it with your camera. If your pen is working, you’ll see the light through your camera’s viewfinder.

Here’s my pen. Notice the bulge in the plastic at the tip? That gives you a sense of the amount of force needed to get the LED holder in. (Kudos to EXPO for using high quality plastic in their products!)

3. Smoothboard software. This is what allows your Wii remote to talk to your computer. It’s not the only software out there, but it has a lot of functionality so it’s the one I recommend. It’s free for educational use, but when you run it, you’ll have to wait 10-15 seconds before the “continue unregistered version” option becomes available. If you like the software, send them $30 to register it.In this blog post, I’m going to just talk about the basic setup, but know that with Smoothboard, you can use a second Wii remote placed in a different spot for redundancy (if you’re standing in front of one, the other one can still ‘see’ the screen; this may also reduce the choppiness that sometimes happens, but I haven’t tried it) or you can use a second one as a ‘presenter’ tool. The latter seems like too much work to me, but you can read the Smoothboard manual and decide for yourself.

[Mac users: Here’s Mac-compatible software.]

4. Classroom Presenter. Okay, this isn’t necessary, but it makes a great smartboard! This free (PC) software (courtesy of the Center for Collaborative Technologies at the University of Washington) was designed for use with TabletPCs. But, when projected on the classroom screen, it gives you terrific smartboard functionality. Of course anything that’s on your computer screen will show up on your classroom screen, but imagine having this:

Load your PowerPoint into Classroom Presenter. Take your infrared pen and, in the toolbar, ‘tap’ the pencil, and write on the slide. Change colors. Switch to the highlighter. Erase individual marks or the entire screen. Quickly ‘tap’ any of the slides on the right to show a new slide. Open a blank screen. When you’re done, save your file, and open it again next class. Or you can save it as html and upload it to your website, course management system, or email to your students. If your computer is WiFi-enabled or is connected to a WiFi network, students with (PC) laptops who are running Classroom Presenter can see your slides on their computer, get your annotations in real time, make their own annotations, and save the file at the end of class. And they can send slides to you in real time, and you can display them for the class. But I digress. For more on this program, again, see my 4/14/2009 blog post.

The classroom setup.

1. Connect your Wii remote to your computer via Bluetooth. Open your computer’s Bluetooth manager, and tell it you’d like to connect a new device. Put your Wii remote in ‘discoverable’ mode. To do this, press and hold the 1 and 2 buttons at the same time. As long as the lights are blinking, it’s ready to be discovered. It will appear in your list as Nintendo RVL-CNT-01. Any time you want to connect your Wii remote, press and hold those 1 and 2 buttons again and then double-click your new Nintendo option in your Bluetooth manager. Presto. It’s connected.

2. Turn on your classroom projector. Once your computer’s screen is displayed, you’re ready to go.

3. Place your Wii remote. This will require a little trial and error to find the best location.

a. To the right or left? Consider how you usually write on the board. You don’t want your back between the pen and the Wii remote. (Better yet, use two remotes, one on each side. Or you can have one remote in closer; that should give greater precision to your writing in the area covered by that closer remote.)

b. How far away? One suggestion, based on a little research, is to take the height of your screen and double it. That’s the distance away from the screen you should place your Wii remote. For example, if your screen is 4 feet high, then your Wii remote should be placed 8 feet away. In my classroom, that worked great. (When I was farther away, the infrared light was too hard for the Wii remote to pick up, and my nice curved line started jumping around all over the place.)

c. How high? The first few times I did this, I found that I tended to point the remote too low. Aim for the middle of the screen. On a desk, I flipped a table-top podium on its side, set 2 textbooks on top of that and then propped a whiteboard eraser under the front of the remote to angle it up a bit. That worked perfectly. Of course a tripod works, too. (Penteractive sells a replacement battery cover for the Wii remote that has a tripod mount built into it.)

4. Run the Smoothboard software. The first thing you need to do is calibrate it. Just press the A button on the Wii remote. Here is the calibration screen:

Notice the circle with the crosshairs in the top left corner? Walk up to your classroom’s screen, put the tip of your infrared pen in the center of the circle, and press the switch. If it’s in your Wii remote’s line of sight, the circle will disappear and then reappear in the top right corner. Repeat this process for all 4 corners. If the circle doesn’t disappear, make sure you’re not standing between the pen and the remote. If you’re not in the way, then that spot is not covered by the Wii remote, and you’ll need to adjust the remote.

This is the Smoothboard interface that shows the battery level on your Wii remote. You can also choose whether you want to use the remote as a whiteboard (which is what we’re using it for) or as a presentation device. I haven’t tried this latter use, so I’ll leave that for someone else to write about.

 

The “Cursor Control Toolbar” puts a little floating toolbar on your screen. Clicking those buttons allows you to do things like mimic a mouse right-click. Very handy.

 

The gray box at the bottom shows the area covered by the Wii remote. The white space shows the area you’re using. The more white space within the gray box, the better. This is telling me that I won’t be able to access the very bottom left of the screen because it’s outside the gray box.

5. Run Classroom Presenter, or whatever other software you’d like. Your infrared pen, when the switch is pressed, now acts like a mouse controlling your cursor. Open programs. Open websites. Write on the screen. Anything you can do with a mouse, you can now do with your infrared pen.

Word of caution.

Writing takes some getting used to. To print words, press the button on the pen, draw your line, stop pressing the button. Repeat for each line. If you write in cursive, you’ll likely have an easier time since each word is one big line. Precision isn’t this tool’s strong point. Think of it as writing with a crayon.

In conclusion…

If you have the money, by all means go with a smartboard or a TabletPC. If you’re looking for some impressive functionality for a cost that is almost covered by the change in your couch, it’s worth trying out.

If you decide to give this a whirl, let me know how it goes!

Advertisements

17 Comments »

  1. Way cool. I think I might actually try this because I’ve already got the Wii remotes.
    Thanks tech master!

    Comment by Jeff Stowell — May 7, 2009 @ 7:48 pm | Reply

    • Funny. Way cool was also my response. I expect to hear from you again before the weekend is out. =)

      Comment by Sue Frantz — May 7, 2009 @ 8:05 pm | Reply

  2. Wow, you sure did get quickly onto it Sue! There’s a link from the Smoothboard site that shows pens you can purchase that have a pressure activated LED making it great for writing as it writes when you press down and stops when you lift off. They even had one that had both pressure sensitive LED and switch.

    Being lazy, I’m going to get some of those shipped over to see how they go. I’ll be using the presenter as well then recording presentations using ePresence (www.epresence.tv) out of University of Toronto.

    Comment by Steve Trickey — May 10, 2009 @ 5:45 am | Reply

    • I saw the pressure-activated pens, but I opted against them for my use because I wasn’t sure how much pressure they needed to activate. The screen in my classroom hangs quite a ways in front of the board making it a flimsy surface. Besides, I didn’t want to wait for a pen to arrive in the mail. My impatience outweighed my laziness. =) [I’ll update this post to include the pressure-activated pen info that I should have included the first time. — Thanks!]

      Comment by Sue Frantz — May 10, 2009 @ 6:54 am | Reply

  3. […] The Smartboard Alternative for $40 « Technology for Educators (tags: cool diy projects wiimote whiteboard) […]

    Pingback by links for 2009-05-18 « Donghai Ma — May 18, 2009 @ 9:06 pm | Reply

  4. I’m a computer teacher, and was wonding if this will work for running Word, Excel, PowerPoint from the board. Can I “click” on Open with the pen, edit and copy, etc., will it complete these operations, or does this only work within the downloaded software?

    Comment by Mr. Osborne — August 11, 2009 @ 2:49 pm | Reply

    • When you run Smoothboard, whatever is on your computer screen is displayed on the classroom screen. The pen acts as a mouse regardless of what program you’re running — Excel, Word, Powerpoint. So, yes, run Smoothboard and open Word, etc. If you try it, let me know how it works for you!

      Comment by Sue Frantz — August 11, 2009 @ 2:55 pm | Reply

    • Smoothboard will work on any application that can receive the mouse and keyboard input.

      In PowerPoint, you can start your slideshow easily by clicking on the floating toolbar or outside screen toggles. Then, you can change slides just by clicking on the arrow button with the preset settings for PowerPoint.

      There is also a built-in annotation tool that will allow you to write on top of any application such as your internet browser, Word, and PowerPoint.

      You can get more information regarding the latest features from http://www.smoothboard.net/features

      Comment by Boon Jin — August 12, 2009 @ 8:37 am | Reply

  5. Thanks for all the times. I bought some pens that arrived today and have been testing out Smoothboard with my laptop. Hopefully I will be able to calibrate easier with my projector in the classroom. I have my projector on a tripod and am hoping I can attach the wii to the projector.

    Comment by Melissa — August 19, 2009 @ 7:14 pm | Reply

    • Excellent! Keep me updated on how it works for you!

      Comment by Sue Frantz — August 20, 2009 @ 7:30 am | Reply

  6. […] Re: wii smart board alternative Check this out: The Smartboard Alternative for $40 Technology for Educators […]

    Pingback by wii smart board alternative - RarityGuide.com Forums — September 18, 2009 @ 8:12 am | Reply

  7. Can I use the Smartboard software already loaded on my machine instead of Smoothware?

    Comment by Warrior — August 26, 2010 @ 3:30 am | Reply

    • The Smoothboard software allows you to connect the Wiimote and turn your ordinary screen surface into an interactive whiteboard with an IR pen.

      As Smoothboard can work with any application that uses the mouse and keyboard, you should be able to use your current Smartboard software too.

      Comment by Boon Jin — August 26, 2010 @ 3:37 am | Reply

  8. I don’t have a projector and don’t want to buy one, i am going to try this tomorrow “blind” .

    wish me luck
    tyson

    Comment by Tyson — November 6, 2010 @ 1:32 am | Reply

    • You can point the Wii remote at your computer monitor, in effect turning your computer monitor into a touchscreen. Have fun!

      Comment by Sue Frantz — November 6, 2010 @ 11:17 am | Reply

  9. […] one post that accounts for 40% of the hits on my blog – 40%, that’s not a typo. It is the Smartboard Alternative post. If you haven’t read it, you’re apparently missing out on something. It’s […]

    Pingback by A Little Reflection « Technology for Educators — November 12, 2010 @ 9:52 am | Reply

  10. […] one post that accounts for 40% of the hits on my blog – 40%, that’s not a typo. It is the Smartboard Alternative post. If you haven’t read it, you’re apparently missing out on something. It’s […]

    Pingback by A Little Reflection | Technology for Educators — December 29, 2010 @ 3:22 pm | Reply


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: